Why picking a builder is a gamble: three things you can't see
Choosing who builds your house is a decision most of us make on trust and a site visit. It's the person you'll trust with your biggest spend, and three things about them are hidden when you hire.
Every figure here is an example, with the arithmetic shown. Your own numbers will differ; the reasons won't.
The record: you only see their best house
You visit a finished home they built. It looks good, and the owner says nice things. Every contractor shows you their best house. You never see the one that ran a year late.
The contractor picks which house you see and which owner you meet. They know which projects overran, which went over budget, and why. You see one result, not the record, so you're judging a whole track record from the best example.
Say your build runs six months late. Rent of ₹40,000 a month and loan interest of ₹80,000 a month add up to ₹7.2 lakh.
6 months × (₹40,000 rent + ₹80,000 interest) = ₹7,20,000
The person you hire may not build your house
You meet the contractor, agree a price and shake hands. Then a different team turns up on site.
Many contractors pass parts of the work to smaller teams. That's normal. But the gap between your price and what they pay the team is their margin, and the cheaper the team, the bigger the margin. Not every contractor works this way. The setup just rewards the cheapest team, not the best one.
Say the contractor keeps 15% between your price and what the site team is paid. On ₹80 lakh of work, that's ₹12 lakh, and the team is the cheapest one they could find.
15% of ₹80 lakh = ₹12,00,000
Turnkey, labour-only or item rate: who carries the risk
Contractors offer different ways to work, and each sounds reasonable when it's explained. Pick the wrong one and you carry risks you didn't know about.
Each one moves the risk to a different person. In turnkey, the contractor buys the materials. In labour-only, you do, so price rises, wastage and delivery delays are yours. Item rate means you pay for what's measured, so how it's measured matters. None of this is explained when you compare prices.
Say labour-only is ₹12 lakh cheaper. Now you buy ₹60 lakh of material yourself. A 5% price rise during the build is ₹3 lakh, plus the time to manage it.
5% of ₹60 lakh material = ₹3,00,000
What it adds up to
Say six months of delay costs ₹7.2 lakh and material price rises cost ₹3 lakh. That's over ₹10 lakh you didn't plan for.
₹7,20,000 + ₹3,00,000 = ₹10,20,000
What you can do
None of this is your fault. A site visit is how most people choose, and a site visit can't show a track record.
The way through is to ask for the record, not the showcase: past clients you pick yourself, how late recent projects ran, who will actually be on site, and which way of working puts which risk on you, in writing.
How to check it yourself
Step by step in our guides: what to look at, and the law, code or practice behind it.